World of Stunting
World of Stunting => World of Stunting Leagues => Topic started by: Mustapha on May 09, 2011, 08:12:45 am
-
Winner Of Match 18(mxz VS PullMan):
Mxz
Winner Of Match 19 ( Edddie VS CloudWalker):
CloudWalker
Winner Of Match 20 (Mustaphs VS BlackDeath):
Mustapha
Winner Of Match 21(Pulp VS WhiteXFul):
WhiteXFul
Winner Of Match 22 ( Sasha VS Aristo VS Bany):
Bany
Judges Will Post Their Opinions In This Topic.
When Judges have posted their opinions, Region 3 will kick off.
-
Match 18:
Pullman: Your usage of freeplay angles was simple & fitting, editingwise, it was really soothing, the camera movements fit very well with the song & the overall atmosphere was enjoyable.
Mxz: your usage of freeplay angles was very creative, perhaps a little excessive, but the ideas were really good nonetheless. Your edit seemed a bit messy, it was hard to follow at times & the colors were a bit bland.
In terms of freeplay usage, my vote goes to Mxz, 'cause his were just more innovative & dynamic, tho I liked Pullman's edit more.
Match 19:
Cloudwalker: That was just perfect, really awesome work. Loved the colors & the choice of effects, the only thing I disliked was the somewhat repetitive opening, but that's just 'cause the amount of stunts are very limited. Really loved this one!
Eddie: That was also really amazing, the CC fit perfectly with the song, so did the effects & all those cuts. But the angles brought the whole vid down quite a lot. There were some camfucks + the angles were really choppy & unsmooth.
My vote goes to Cloudwalker
Match 20:
Mustapha: I already reviewed this on GTAS, some of those effects are really fitting & blend in good good with the whole thing, some parts didn't seem to have any sync, or were way off, try to avoid random effects.
Match 21:
White: The editing was nice as a whole, those shakes were a bit too massive at times & some of those pan/crop movements were unnecessary, regardless, it was a pretty solid edit with nice pace & atmosphere, except for 1 thing: There wasn't much of creativity going on there, you could've experimented more with some effects, media generators, masking & stuff to make it more of a creative edit.
Pulp: *waiting*
Match 22:
Sasha: Really nice editing in general, tho there were some parts that could've been better. For starters, I really disliked that CC, it was way too dull & overbright for my taste, didn't really look that good. The very beginning & the first taxi stunt angle both seemed kinda slow & uninteresting, in contrast with the speed ups & more vivid parts of the editing, so that made kinda bad balance, the first angle on the taxi stunt was also really lazy & boring. Other than that, it was a really solid entry, the sync & the effects were great & fitting.
Aristo: No-show
Bany: Pretty nice entry, really liked the colors & some of the effects you picked. The big downside would be the excessive use of steady angles, with songs like these, it's really a bad idea to make still, uninvolved angles. You could've at least added some pan/crop to create motion. The first part of the vid was really good, with a lot of nice syncing, the 2nd 1 was lacking in the use of effects tho, something as simple as noise or tv sim would make that part much better imo (talking about the last stunt).
My vote goes to Sasha, 'cause his entry was more vivid & energetic & the effects weren't as random.
Let's wait for others to submit
-
Thanks Determined. Thanks for telling me the wrong things about my entry, so I will not make the same mistakes next time, lol I really did a ultra mega mistake on the second stunt, I didn't show the last part, it was a grind.
-
i'll lose :huh:
Cya mxZ <_<
-
Match 18
Pullman:Your freeplay angles were simple and good, the camera movements were great with the music.
Mxz:The freeplay angles used were very good, the edit was amazing too.
Mxz wins
Match 19
Cloudwalker:The edit was amesome. The music was great with the effects used and the colors too.
Edddie:The edit was nice. The CC was great, but the angles were not the best.
CloudWalker wins
Match 20
Mustapha wins by no-show
Match 21
White wins.
Match 22
Sasha:The edit was not the best, because the CC and the angles used were not good. The speed ups and the angles used on the stunts are not good together.
Bany:I liked the colors and effects used. The effects used are well synched with the music.
Bany wins.
-
1.my name is White/Whitey
2.Cmon pulp.I don't wanna win by no-show
-
Other judges? :huh:
-
Match 17
Basium wins by no-show.
Match 18
Mxz
Match 19
Cloudwalker.
Match 20
Mustapha wins by no-show.
Match 21
WhitexFull wins (idk, but its pending)
Match 22
Bany.
I wont explain since last time organizer pissed me off, coz of my judging...
-
Mxz:The freeplay angles used were very good, the edit was amazing too.
the angles are not what matters, what matters is the knack that you use their cams ...
-
Mxz:The freeplay angles used were very good, the edit was amazing too.
the angles are not what matters, what matters is the knack that you use their cams ...
What was the objective?
read again, irmao.
-
Mxz:The freeplay angles used were very good, the edit was amazing too.
the angles are not what matters, what matters is the knack that you use their cams ...
The objective was the BEST usage, not the edit with the most freecam you can use.
-
i lol'd at some of the replys i got, really this editing tournament was so unorganized....
-
^We all know this, they are beginners in tournament, I guess we should let them improve.
-
i lol'd at some of the replys i got, really this editing tournament was so unorganized....
What do you mean?
OT: Do Pulp, BD & Aristo still have time to post their entries, or are they out? Kinda confused, since it says "pending" on their vids instead of No-Showed, so clear that up please.
-
i lol'd at some of the replys i got, really this editing tournament was so unorganized....
What do you mean?
OT: Do Pulp, BD & Aristo still have time to post their entries, or are they out? Kinda confused, since it says "pending" on their vids instead of No-Showed, so clear that up please.
why do u think I put a cross over aristo
-
Ok then, I'll update that now.
-
Pulp's entry or gtfo
-
Mine
Match 17
Basium wins by no-show.
Match 18
Mxz
Match 19
Cloudwalker.
Match 20
Mustapha wins by no-show.
Match 21
WhitexFull wins
Match 22
Bany.
-
(http://cheezburger.com/Builder/RenderPreview/eef84ab1-53a9-433d-87e2-ce286d4faa97)
-
(http://cheezburger.com/Builder/RenderPreview/eef84ab1-53a9-433d-87e2-ce286d4faa97)
Goto Mike's post, he clearly explained why
-
No, just no. A judge is pretty much like a critic, he can't just rate a movie without explaining what he based his rating on, he mustn't give a fuck about some whining, even if it's an error on his side, considering, that he's new to the whole judging business & editing in general. If you have made a choice, then there's definitely a reason why you've chosen 1 over the other & all you have to do is just write that reason down maintaining constructivism & helping the editor see his errors. Just fucking state your opinion, you must have one, if you don't, then you're not fit to be a judge, if you have one, but you're afraid of expressing it - you're weak & inconfident - not fit to be a judge.
Just try to show some effort from your side, your goal is to help these editors improve & nothing does it better than constructive criticism & "ability" to state your own opinion on his work.
-
Right, so your point is, because these judges don't review, the blame all goes for me right.
I'm already facing much problems in real life yet I try to do something about this Tournament.
Yes I will take your "advice" into account, and go more stricter about this reviewing, because it can make a change.
-
Mxz wins right?
-
^There are 5judges, I've got 4vote, so yea, I guess.
-
Got problems??
Remove me, i dont realy care, when i make a simple review, everyone says shit, what i realy hateits when i get spamed in xfire coz of a begger that says: "ZOMG, remove your review about (Pullman or WhitxFul) or hes gonna kill me"
Most of you will be like: WTF this guy want?, but the guy who said me this will understand.
Cheers.
-
Got problems??
Remove me, i dont realy care, when i make a simple review, everyone says shit, what i realy hateits when i get spamed in xfire coz of a begger that says: "ZOMG, remove your review about (Pullman or WhitxFul) or hes gonna kill me"
Most of you will be like: WTF this guy want?, but the guy who said me this will understand.
Cheers.
Why don't you just say who it was?
Yes, it was me duh? but then you behave in the way you are at the moment, when I actually considered giving you the place for you to be a judge, after YOU BEGGED me.
No I'm not against you, just forwarding facts.
Round 3 will start tomorrow, for the rest of the guys.
-
You people really need to get some facts and stop arguing. This tournament was started by a normal player of WoS who wanted to bring up something to do for others to have some fun since all we had before were Stunting Leagues. So idea was to get some editing competition for those who wanted it. This tournament wasn't supposed to be professional, just a friendly competition among friends and of course everyone else was also welcome. Determined you showed what a real judge for editing tournament is that's for sure, you've got lots of experiences with it I can tell. I also understand what you were trying to say about the explanations but judging here on this tournament was supposed to be more simple, and not being looked into microscope. I've been asked for judging and I said that I have no big experience with editing, but still I know some basics and have a good sense for deciding the better. So I said I'll do it since this was supposed to be a simple friendly tournament.
From my point of view about judging on editing of what I look on is mostly sync with music and how well the effects fits. I don't know how every effect is called also so when explaining I keep it nice and simple. I look at it very carefully and simply chose of what I think it looks better for my style of editing and I still stand with my decisions I made. And I believe most of the judges did the same, chose from their "style of what a good edit is" so you should simply respect that. Also explanations were about to be skipped as it always causes drama, but I've spoke to every judge and most of them said it's fine and we can give the explains if you guys want to, but as you see it caused drama and now from what I see there wont be any explains anymore.
Also no-one was expecting that this tournament will become so big and full of GTAS who needs more professional approche or how could I call it. So you're getting a bit unfair to Mustapha, this was his first tournament and when it grown that big it also put lots of burden on his shoulders as he knew requirements have changed. He knew he'll have to make it more professional to please your requirements. That's why I also helped him out there and make some space on the forums for it to be pulled off. He's doing his best and worrying for this to work nicely for all of you and all you do is complain. So everyone stop bitching and deal with it of how it is and have fun!
Regards,
Nka19