World of Stunting > World of Stunting Leagues

Final Results.

(1/5) > >>

Mustapha:
CloudWalker has gained 3rd place award, his award will be made later during the day.


Mxz vs Whitey - Winner:


This has been a wonderful tournament, I really unexpected this outcome, thanks guys for everything!

Judges will post their thoughts here.

mxz:
Yay :D

MikeKnight:
Mxz vs. Whitey

mxz: yours edit fitted the challenge better since the challenge was   best over edit / creative ideas blabla.....   even thou yours did not have any new ideas in my eyes  and your angles were bit too close ... it was still  nicely over edited ...

White: there was few effects wich looked bad imo   and  there was a small camfuck in the start ..but i can guess its not your fault  your intro was   rly cool and cc  was good too



My vote goes to mxz  ( hard to decide but since the chall was over edit so...  )  good job all contestants 

CW:
Lol thanks guys!  :ph34r:

Determined:
White: the intro was really nice, liked the white/red color scheme & the depth of field effects. the editing was really nice, liked the way you used the cinematic camera angles, the cc was dark & beautiful, really complementing the ambient atmosphere, tho you could've adjusted brightness/contrast on the freeway stunt, as it was way too dark on that one. Nice notice of the heli on that last stunt, I've always tried to land a stunt exactly when it flies by, but I've never managed that :D Kudos to that. Really loved the blur effects & the tv sync on the freeway stunt, fitsgoodman.

Mxz: your edit was a total contrast of White's. Where White's edit was soothing & laid back, yours was totally energetic & vivid, it kept me pumped up for the whole vid, which was awesome. The intro really played it's part here, it really prepared you for what's coming & made you feel anxious to see what happens next, so you got me hooked from the very beginning. The effects were all over the place, at some parts, they could've been synced better or made a bit more fitting to the depth of the beats, but in general they were really well-crafted and fitting, tho I was expecting some more tv simulator for this kinda song. The cc was nice, but it could've used a stronger vignette, with more brightened center, imo that would've made the effects better looking as well. I would also like to address the ending, 'cause imo, it was a great way to end the vid, the beat was just perfect for cutting it off & it really felt like an actual ending & you don't see that too often for such short vids.

Really, really, really, REALLY TOUGH DECISION. If the objective was different, I swear, I'd have no choice but to vote tie. you both did an amazing, excellent work & you've come to prove that you both are indeed great editors who can work in different spheres & make the best of it, whether it'd be pumped up overediting, or creating an exhilarating atmosphere that pulls the viewer in & making him see the vid in a whole different perspective than he usually would. I'm voting for Mxz just because he completed the objective better then White, in my eyes, this is a complete tie if you take the objective out.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page