WoS Banner Attempts

Started by Zencal, June 15, 2008, 11:52:10 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

macress345

omg noobs bumping old topics  

nos

I ain't no noob you boob.

Zencal

Quote from: nosHonestly, this is horrible.

I just love how idiots don't understand a thing about constructive criticism.

  • What's wrong with it?
  • What could be improved?

I realise that this isn't my best work, but I figured that a more plain look would suit the skin better. I would also love to see some of your horrible stuff also before I take your comment more seriously.

nos

Sorry jackass, how can i give criticism when 7 other noobs are saying "This is so good" and shit like that? Since it's so good, why should i?

But you wanted a honest answer and ill give it to you.

First of all, im guessing you made this in Photoshop correct? Im not a pro, or a noob at it, but i would say ameuteur.

To begin, all you did was lower the opacity of the text, and slapped on a crappy stock photo.

30 second banner ftl.

How can you improve...hmm...

honestly, i...don't...know.

JaTochNietDan

Quote from: nosSorry jackass, how can i give criticism when 7 other noobs are saying "This is so good" and shit like that? Since it's so good, why should i?

But you wanted a honest answer and ill give it to you.

First of all, im guessing you made this in Photoshop correct? Im not a pro, or a noob at it, but i would say ameuteur.

To begin, all you did was lower the opacity of the text, and slapped on a crappy stock photo.

30 second banner ftl.

How can you improve...hmm...

honestly, i...don't...know.
So your judging people based on their personal opinion about a graphic. Your sounding quite mature yourself.

Standards

Wow haven't heard from Zencal in a while. Nice banners. The simpler the better.

Zencal

Quote from: nosSorry jackass, how can I give criticism when 7 other noobs are saying "This is so good" and shit like that? Since it's so good, why should I?

But you wanted a honest answer and ill give it to you.

First of all, I'm guessing you made this in Photoshop correct? I'm not a pro, or a noob at it, but i would say amateur's.

To begin, all you did was lower the opacity of the text, and slapped on a crappy stock photo.

30 second banner ftl.

How can you improve...hmm...

honestly, I...don't...know.

So according to you, using 3 brushes from a brush set and playing around untill you got a good pattern, planning on where you would put them, and starting again if something goes wrong is a crappy stock photo with some text slapped on in 30 seconds? I understand that the others are not giving constructive criticism either, yet you didn't need to be such a jackass, especially when you seem to be unable to identify a brushed background from a stock image?

Off Topic: I also spell checked your grammar for you.

milo34

Dident even have to try Made JA dan the banner thats up ther he liked it from da start xD